Electricity: A Privilege Or A Right? The Edgewater Dilemma

should edgewater be deprived of electric or

In the video game The Outer Worlds, players are faced with a crucial decision: whether to redirect power to Edgewater or the Deserters at the Botanical Lab. This decision has significant consequences and impacts the player's reputation with the two factions. Siding with Edgewater means supporting the corporation Spacer's Choice, while redirecting power to the Deserters aids those fighting against corporate control. The player must carefully consider their choice, weighing the potential outcomes and the impact on their in-game relationships.

Characteristics Values
Game The Outer Worlds
Quest Comes Now the Power
Choice Redirect power to Edgewater or the Botanical Lab
Result Someone will be hurt no matter the choice
Edgewater Siding with Edgewater is siding with the corporation Spacer's Choice
Botanical Lab Siding with the Botanical Lab will help the Deserters fighting against the corporations
Edgewater (consequences) Increase in reputation with Spacer's Choice, 2,828 XP, and the 'Permanently Save Edgewater' trophy
Botanical Lab (consequences) Increase in reputation with the Deserters, 15,000 XP, and the quickest resolution to the quest
Botanical Lab (consequences) Parvati may leave the party if Reed is killed
Edgewater (strategy) Convince the Deserters to return to Edgewater or deal with Reed for Adelaide
Edgewater (strategy) Kill Reed Tobson or convince him to step down and let Adelaide take his job
Botanical Lab (strategy) Kill Reed and his men for the Power Regulator or convince him to stand down

shunzap

The consequences of redirecting power to Edgewater

Player's Reputation

Redirecting power to Edgewater improves the player's reputation with Spacer's Choice, the corporation that controls the town. This can lead to various faction bonuses such as vendor discounts. However, it negatively impacts the player's reputation with the Deserters, a group fighting against corporate control.

The Deserters' Reaction

The Deserters, led by Adelaide McDevitt, are not happy with the decision to redirect power to Edgewater. They view it as sentencing them to a "lifetime of slavery" under Edgewater's management. Adelaide refuses to return to Edgewater and would rather die than live under its control. This can lead to a breakdown in negotiations and potential conflict between the player and the Deserters.

Negotiations and Conflict

The player has the option to negotiate with the Deserters and try to persuade them to return to Edgewater. This can be challenging, as Adelaide is adamant about continuing her research for a cure. The player might need to convince Reed, the administrator of Edgewater, to step down or find a peaceful resolution. Killing Reed is an option, but it can lead to permanent negative consequences, such as the Deserters becoming hostile and the player's companion, Parvati, leaving the party.

The Unreliable and Quest Completion

Redirecting power to Edgewater provides the necessary power regulator to fly The Unreliable ship again. It also completes the "Comes Now The Power" quest and can unlock the trophy to "Permanently Save Edgewater." The player's choice impacts the potential endings, with redirecting power to Edgewater offering two different outcomes depending on whether Reed remains in control.

Overall, the consequences of redirecting power to Edgewater are complex and depend on the player's skills, choices, and interactions with the various factions and characters in the game. The decision has moral implications and can shape the player's experience and relationships within the game world.

shunzap

The consequences of redirecting power to the Botanical Lab

In the Outer Worlds, players are faced with a crucial decision that will have significant consequences: whether to redirect power to the town of Edgewater or the Deserters at the Botanical Lab. This decision is part of the "Comes Now The Power" quest, where the player must find a power regulator for their ship, The Unreliable, by choosing which faction to take it from.

Consequences of Redirecting Power to the Botanical Lab

  • Increased reputation with the Deserters: Choosing to side with the Deserters will boost your reputation with them. This can lead to potential benefits such as vendor discounts or other faction bonuses.
  • Negative reputation with Spacer's Choice: Redirecting power to the Botanical Lab will negatively impact your reputation with Spacer's Choice, the corporation that controls Halcyon. This may result in decreased faction bonuses from them.
  • Confrontation with Reed Tobson: If you return to Edgewater's Saltuna Cannery, you will be confronted by administrator Reed Tobson, who will threaten you and send his guards after you. You can either choose to fight, which may lead to Reed's death and the failure of all remaining quests in Edgewater, or use your Intimidate skill to convince him to stand down.
  • Potential loss of Parvati as a companion: If Reed is killed, Parvati, a fan-favorite companion, may leave your party permanently. Passing a Determination/Lie check can convince her to stay.
  • Dooming Edgewater: Redirecting power to the Botanical Lab essentially dooms Edgewater, as they lose access to a crucial resource.
  • Impact on Adelaide and the Deserters: While Adelaide McDevitt, the leader of the Deserters, will initially be angry about being deprived of power, there are options to resolve the situation. You can either convince the Deserters to return to Edgewater, which requires completing their side quests, or remove Reed from his position, allowing Adelaide to become the community's leader.
  • Chaotic resolution: Redirecting power to the Botanical Lab is described as the more chaotic option, as it may involve killing multiple guards and automechanicals, in addition to the confrontation with Reed.
  • Quickest resolution: Choosing the Botanical Lab is the quickest way to resolve the quest, especially if you intend to fight back against the corporations, regardless of the consequences.

shunzap

The impact of the player's decision on their reputation with Spacer's Choice

In The Outer Worlds, players are faced with a crucial decision that will impact their reputation with Spacers Choice. The decision revolves around whether to redirect power to Edgewater, siding with the corporation Spacer's Choice, or to the Deserters at the Botanical Lab, who are fighting against the company's control.

If players choose to divert power to Edgewater, their reputation with Spacer's Choice will increase. This decision can be justified by the belief that the Deserters will eventually return to Edgewater, and it is better for the town to thrive under Reed or Adelaide's leadership. Additionally, players may have a personal preference for siding with corporate entities.

However, redirecting power to Edgewater will negatively impact the player's reputation with the Deserters. Adelaide McDevitt, the leader of the Deserters, will be furious with the player's decision, claiming that they have sentenced her people to a "lifetime of slavery in Edgewater". She adamantly refuses to return to Edgewater and would rather die than live under Reed's management. This decision can lead to a chaotic scenario, as players may need to fight guards and kill automechanicals to retrieve the power regulator from the Deserters.

On the other hand, choosing to support the Deserters by diverting power to the Botanical Lab will increase the player's reputation with them while decreasing their standing with Spacer's Choice. This decision aligns with a more revolutionary or anti-corporate sentiment. Adelaide McDevitt believes she is liberating the oppressed people of Edgewater, and players may sympathize with her cause.

Ultimately, the decision to support Edgewater or the Deserters is a nuanced one, and both choices have consequences for the player's reputation with Spacers Choice and the respective factions. Players must weigh their values and the potential outcomes before making their choice.

shunzap

The impact of the player's decision on their reputation with the Deserters

In The Outer Worlds, the first major decision players have to make is whether to redirect power to the town of Edgewater or the Deserters at the Botanical Lab. This decision will have an impact on the player's reputation with the Deserters.

If the player chooses to redirect power to Edgewater, the Deserters will not be happy. When the player returns to them and speaks with Adelaide, she will be angry and claim that they have sentenced the Deserters to a "lifetime of slavery in Edgewater". The player can try to persuade the Deserters to return to Edgewater or tell Adelaide that they are willing to deal with Reed for her. This can be done by killing Reed or convincing him to step down and let Adelaide take his job. If the player chooses this path, they will need to have high enough stats.

On the other hand, if the player chooses to redirect power to the Deserters, their reputation with the Deserters will increase. This decision will also affect the player's reputation with Spacer's Choice, the corporation that controls Halcyon, which will decrease. The player will then need to fight Reed and his men for the Power Regulator back at the cannery. The player can convince Reed to stand down if they have high enough speech skills, but the whole town will lose power.

Overall, the player's decision to redirect power to either Edgewater or the Deserters will have an impact on their reputation with the Deserters. Choosing Edgewater will initially hurt their reputation, but there is an opportunity to improve it by persuading the Deserters to return or dealing with Reed. Choosing the Deserters will increase the player's reputation with them, but it will hurt their reputation with Spacer's Choice.

shunzap

The potential for a balanced outcome

The Outer Worlds is a video game that presents players with a moral dilemma: whether to redirect power to the town of Edgewater or to the Deserters at the Botanical Lab. The decision is a nuanced one, as both options have positive and negative consequences.

Redirecting power to Edgewater means siding with the corporation Spacer's Choice, which will increase the player's reputation with this faction. This option can lead to the player convincing the Deserters to return to Edgewater, or removing the Edgewater leader, Reed Tobson, and installing Adelaide McDevitt as the new leader. However, if the player chooses to remove Reed, they risk him ordering his guards to kill them, and they will have to fight Reed and his men for the Power Regulator. This option dooms the Deserters.

On the other hand, redirecting power to the Botanical Lab means siding with the Deserters, who are fighting back against the corporations. This option will increase the player's reputation with the Deserters, but decrease it with Spacer's Choice. The Deserters will initially be unhappy with this decision, but the player can convince them to return to Edgewater, or remove Reed from his position of power. However, if the player chooses to remove Reed, they risk the permanent departure of their companion Parvati, and they will have to kill a bunch of guards and automechanicals to reach the power regulator. This option dooms Edgewater.

The most balanced outcome, therefore, may be to divert power to Edgewater, so that the town can thrive under either Reed or Adelaide's leadership. This option also allows the player to unlock the trophy to 'Permanently Save Edgewater'. However, it is worth noting that there is no perfect outcome, and no matter which option the player chooses, someone will be hurt. Additionally, there is no special reward for either option, and the player's reputation with both factions will be affected.

Frequently asked questions

The first main conflict in The Outer Worlds is Edgewater vs Deserters, where two factions battle for resources. The player has to decide whether to redirect power to Edgewater or the Deserters at the Botanical Lab.

If you redirect power to Edgewater, the Deserters will be unhappy. Adelaide McDevitt will refuse to return to Edgewater and will ask you to deal with Reed Tobson. You can either kill Reed or convince him to step down.

If you redirect power to the Deserters, you will have to fight Reed and his men for the Power Regulator. You can convince him to stand down if your speech skills are high enough, but the whole town will lose power.

There is no way to completely avoid conflict in this quest. However, you can take extra steps to achieve a slightly better ending. For example, you can complete side quests for the Deserters to convince them to return to Edgewater before redirecting power.

Written by
Reviewed by

Explore related products

Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment