Israel-Gaza Electricity Conundrum: Who Pays?

does israel give free electricity to gaza

Israel has been accused of providing insufficient electricity to Gaza, with some sources claiming that Israel has a legal and moral obligation to provide electricity to the region. Israel controls all access in and out of the Gaza Strip, and they have been accused of using this control to restrict electricity to Gaza. Israel's electricity company supplies power to Gaza through 10 lines, and the Gaza Power Plant is another source of electricity for the region. However, Israel has been accused of banning the entry of fuel used for the power plant and directly targeting the plant and electric power lines during conflicts. This has resulted in an energy crisis in Gaza, with 2 million Palestinians living without reliable access to electricity.

Characteristics Values
Who controls access to the Gaza Strip? Israel
Who supplies electricity to Gaza? Israel Electric Corporation (IEC), Egypt, and the Gaza Power Plant
Is electricity free? No, IEC charges approximately $11 million per month
Who pays for the electricity? The Palestinian Authority (PA)
Is there an electricity crisis in Gaza? Yes
What are the causes of the electricity crisis? Tensions between Hamas and the PA, restricted supply of fuel, and targeting of the Gaza Power Plant and power lines during conflicts
What are the impacts of the electricity crisis? Lack of access to basic humanitarian needs such as health, water, and sanitation services
Has the Israeli Supreme Court ruled on the matter? Yes, in 2008 the Court ruled that Israel has a legal obligation to ensure basic humanitarian aid reaches Gaza civilians during armed conflict

shunzap

Israel's legal obligation to provide electricity to Gaza

Israel has been the main supplier of electricity to the Gaza Strip. However, Israel's decision to restrict electricity supply to Gaza has led to an energy crisis in the region. This decision has been labelled as "dangerous and catastrophic" by Hamas, which has ruled Gaza since 2007.

Israel's control over entry points into Gaza has allowed it to restrict the supply of fuel to the power plant, leading to reduced electricity production. Additionally, there have been accusations of Israel's military forces directly targeting the Gaza Power Plant and electric power lines during conflicts, further limiting access to electricity for Palestinians in Gaza.

Israel has acknowledged a minimal humanitarian obligation to provide electricity and fuel to the Gaza Strip and to prevent a humanitarian crisis. The Supreme Court of Israel has affirmed that Israel has ongoing duties towards the Gaza Strip due to the past years of Israeli military rule in the territory, resulting in the region's near-complete dependence on Israeli electricity supply.

Israel's obligations extend beyond merely being a service provider and include finding solutions to maintain and increase the supply of electricity to allow residents to maintain acceptable living conditions. Israel's own military and political figures have recognized that improving living conditions in Gaza is in its interests, as it reduces the risk of unnecessary hostilities.

shunzap

The role of the Palestinian Authority (PA) in electricity supply

The Palestinian Authority (PA) has played a significant role in the electricity supply to Gaza. The PA collects import duties on Gaza's fuel purchased via Israel, as per the Protocol on Economic Relations. This money is then used to pay Israel and Egypt for the electricity they supply to Gaza.

In April 2017, the PA stopped paying the electricity bills issued by the Israel Electric Corporation (IEC), leading to a further deterioration of the already fragile living conditions in Gaza. This decision was reversed in January 2018. During the early stages of the Gaza War, Israel shut off the supply of electricity to Gaza, causing the sole remaining power plant to run out of fuel.

The PA has also been involved in disputes with Hamas, which rules in Gaza, over custom tax revenue, funding of Gaza, and political authority. These tensions have contributed to the electricity crisis in Gaza. In 2017, the PA told IEC that it would only pay a portion of the monthly bill for Gaza's electricity and instructed IEC to reduce the supply. This led to a dispute between the PA and Hamas, with Hamas blaming the PA for the crisis and the PA claiming that Hamas officials were incapable of running the power plant efficiently.

The PA's role in the electricity supply to Gaza has been a complex and contentious issue, with the PA having the power to impact the availability of essential services and the economy in Gaza. The PA's decisions and disputes with Hamas have had significant consequences for the people of Gaza, highlighting the delicate balance of power in the region.

shunzap

Impact on humanitarian conditions and human rights in Gaza

The ongoing electricity crisis in the Gaza Strip has had a significant negative impact on the lives of its citizens, worsening the already difficult humanitarian situation and deteriorating economic conditions. The crisis is predominantly the result of tensions between Hamas, which has ruled Gaza since 2007, and the Palestinian Authority (PA) and Fatah, which rules in the West Bank, over custom tax revenue, funding of Gaza, and political authority.

The lack of reliable electricity has directly impacted the quality of life of individuals in Gaza, and it has also made it difficult for humanitarian efforts to provide aid. The United Nations human rights office and Israeli human rights group B'Tselem have both expressed deep concern over the deteriorating humanitarian conditions and the protection of human rights in Gaza. The limited supply of electricity, often less than four hours a day, has severely impacted essential health, water, and sanitation services.

The electricity crisis has led to damage to electrical equipment, increased physical and mental health issues, and a higher cost of living. About 77% of citizens face challenges in completing basic household tasks, such as storing food and vegetables in refrigerators, and suffer from the heat during the summer due to the inability to cool their environment. Additionally, the lack of electricity has resulted in untreated sewage being directed into the sea, severely polluting Gaza's beaches and affecting both Gaza and Israeli coastal areas.

While Israel has denied responsibility for the crisis, the Israeli Supreme Court ruled in 2008 that even during times of declared war, Israel has a legal obligation to ensure basic humanitarian aid reaches Gaza civilians. This includes the provision of vital humanitarian goods such as food, water, and fuel, which are still able to enter through Egypt. However, the ongoing conflict and blockade have made it challenging to secure consistent fuel supplies and maintain the power infrastructure in Gaza.

shunzap

Accusations of Israel's military forces targeting Gaza Power Plant

On July 29, 2014, during the 2014 Gaza War, the Gaza Power Plant was hit by Israeli shelling, causing a fire that forced a complete shutdown of the power plant. This resulted in a blackout across all of Gaza and worsened the humanitarian crisis for the territory's 1.7 million people. The power plant's director, Mohammed al-Sharif, stated that the plant was "finished," and political scientist Mkhaimer Abusada predicted that "all of Gaza is going to collapse" as a result.

Israel denied targeting the power plant, with Brig. Gen. Yaron Rosen stating that the facility may have been hit by accident and that the matter was under investigation. An army spokesman confirmed that the plant was not a target. However, witnesses in Gaza reported that missiles had been fired from Israeli F-16s, and the director of the plant, Mohammed al-Sharif, claimed that the attack constituted "collective punishment against the Palestinians."

The shutdown of the power plant had far-reaching consequences beyond power outages. It disrupted the pumping of water to households, the treatment of sewage, and the food supply, as refrigerators stopped working and bakeries were forced to reduce bread production. Hospitals, already overwhelmed with war casualties, had to rely on precarious generators.

Israel has a history of attacking power plants in hostilities outside of Gaza. During its conflict with Hezbollah, Israel deliberately bombed electricity plants in southern Lebanon on multiple occasions, violating the laws of war prohibiting disproportionate attacks that cause greater harm to civilians than military gain.

The electricity crisis in the Gaza Strip is predominantly due to tensions between Hamas, which governs Gaza, and the Palestinian Authority (PA) and Fatah, which rules the West Bank. The Hamas government in Gaza relies on the PA for assistance in providing electricity, with import duties on fuel purchased via Israel being collected by Israel and passed to the PA, which then pays Israel and Egypt for the electricity they supply to Gaza. In April 2017, the PA ceased paying electricity bills to Israel and Egypt, causing a temporary shutdown of the Gaza power plant. During the early stages of the Gaza War, Israel also shut off the supply of electricity to Gaza.

shunzap

Egypt's offer to supply electricity in exchange for security demands

The electricity crisis in the Gaza Strip is an ongoing issue faced by nearly two million residents, with regular power supply being provided for only a few hours a day. The crisis is largely a result of tensions between Hamas, the Palestinian Authority (PA), and Fatah, which rules in the West Bank, over custom tax revenue, funding of Gaza, and political authority.

In April 2017, the PA stopped paying the electricity bills issued by the Israel Electric Corporation (IEC) and Egypt, causing the sole remaining power station to run out of fuel in October 2023. During the 2014 Gaza War, the power plant was hit by Israeli shelling, and by 2015, it was operating at partial capacity due to restricted fuel supplies.

Egypt has offered to supply electricity to Gaza in exchange for security demands. In June 2017, Egypt proposed providing 500 tons of diesel fuel daily in return for the extradition of 17 wanted terrorists, a crackdown on security along the border with Sinai, and a halt to weapons smuggling into the Sinai Peninsula. Hamas has warned that Israel's decision to reduce electricity could lead to violence.

The PA's strategy to squeeze Hamas out of power includes cutting government salaries and reducing medical aid to the Strip. Israel and the PA argue that Hamas has the funds to meet Gaza's power needs but chooses to allocate resources to armament and conflict preparation. The Israeli military and the UN have cautioned that the electricity crisis could lead to military hostilities.

Frequently asked questions

No, Israel does not give free electricity to Gaza. In fact, Israel has been accused of deliberately limiting access to electricity for Palestinians in Gaza. Israel controls all entry points into Gaza and has been known to restrict the supply of fuel to the Gaza Power Plant.

Yes, Israel does supply electricity to Gaza, but it is not free. Israel's electricity company supplies power through 10 lines. Israel Electric Corporation (IEC) charges approximately $11 million per month for electricity, deducting the sum from the transfers of Palestinian tax revenues that Israel collects on the PA's behalf.

Yes, there is an ongoing electricity crisis in Gaza, with residents facing rolling blackouts and receiving electricity for only a few hours a day. This has had a severe impact on essential health, water, and sanitation services.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment