The Benefits Of Hydroelectric Dams: Why Build More?

why not build more hydro electric dams

Hydropower is a good source of low-carbon electricity, and there is room for it to grow. However, countries need to weigh the benefits of hydropower against the environmental and social costs of dam projects. Large hydroelectric dams can't be built just anywhere, as they require a consistent supply of water and a large amount of land. Additionally, dams and reservoirs can reduce river flows, raise water temperatures, degrade water quality, and cause sediment buildup, which can negatively impact fish populations. Furthermore, hydro resources often require a long-term investment horizon, which may not be feasible for all countries. While hydropower has potential, most countries may choose not to develop it extensively, and instead, focus on other renewable energy sources like solar and wind power.

shunzap

Dams displace people and negatively impact wildlife

Hydroelectric dams are known to have adverse effects on the environment and local communities. They are considered a threat to fish habitats worldwide, impacting migratory fish species that tens of millions of people rely on for food and livelihoods. Dams can also collect harmful mercury, contaminating fish and, by extension, humans. The construction and operation of dams can also result in the displacement of local populations.

The construction of dams requires a consistent supply of water and a large amount of land, which is why they are often built in low-lying areas along rivers. These areas, known as riparian zones, are perfect for plants that need constant moisture and a specific soil type. However, the flooding caused by dam construction can destroy these habitats, along with the terrestrial and aquatic organisms that depend on them.

Dams can also reduce river flows, raise water temperatures, degrade water quality, and cause sediment to build up. This sedimentation can destroy native habitats above and below the dam, further impacting the biodiversity of the river ecosystem. In some cases, the completion of a single dam can decrease habitat connectivity by a significant margin, as in the case of the Purari River in Papua New Guinea.

The impacts of hydropower development are disproportionately high in developing countries, where dams are often built to expand electricity access rather than replace fossil fuel resources. This can result in the violation of the rights of Indigenous peoples to their lands, territories, resources, and cultural practices. Additionally, the large-scale nature of hydropower projects makes them vulnerable to the impacts of climate change, such as droughts, which can cripple electricity generation and lead to energy rationing and blackouts.

shunzap

There are limited suitable locations for new dams

Hydropower is the largest source of renewable electricity and one of the fastest-growing, but there are limited places to build hydropower plants. Firstly, hydro plants need a consistent supply of water and a large amount of land. Some countries have plenty of these resources, while others do not.

Secondly, hydropower plants and dams can also negatively impact the environment and society. Dams and reservoirs can reduce river flows, raise water temperature, degrade water quality, and cause sediment to build up. This can negatively impact fish, birds, and other wildlife, and these effects can spill over to humans. For example, the World Bank estimated in 2000 that between 40 and 80 million people had been directly displaced by dams and reservoirs. Another study from 2010 estimated that 472 million people downstream from large dams suffer from reduced food security, regular flooding, or impacts on their livelihood.

Thirdly, hydropower plants and dams can be expensive and time-consuming to build. Hydro resources often require a very long-term investment horizon. When investing in building a hydro reservoir, it is usually part of a very big economic development strategy over a couple of decades. In addition, the cost of hydropower installation has been increasing. A 2022 IRENA report found that the cost of hydropower installation rose 62% between 2010 and 2021, while the cost of solar power installation dropped 82% during the same period.

Lastly, there are already thousands of existing dams that could be retrofitted to generate electricity. According to the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), retrofitting existing dams could add as much as 12,000 megawatts of generation capacity to the grid. Therefore, there is limited suitable location for new dams as there are alternative options to generate electricity from hydropower.

Electric Monopoly: APS's Grip on Power

You may want to see also

shunzap

Retrofitting existing dams is a more sustainable option

Retrofitting existing dams to generate hydropower is a more sustainable option than building new dams. There are more than 90,000 dams in the United States, but only about 2,500 generate power, providing about 7% of the country's electricity and 38% of its renewable electricity. This means there is a huge opportunity to leverage existing infrastructure to generate more hydropower while avoiding the environmental and social costs of building new dams.

Retrofitting dams with hydroelectric generation capabilities can tap into water already flowing through the infrastructure, expanding the supply of domestic, renewable energy. It also helps to safeguard the state of watersheds, as reservoirs can reduce river flows, raise water temperatures, degrade water quality, and cause sediment buildup, which negatively impacts wildlife and humans alike.

The World Bank estimated in 2000 that between 40 and 80 million people had been directly displaced by dams and reservoirs. Another study from 2010 estimated that 472 million people downstream from large dams suffer from reduced food security, regular flooding, or impacts on their livelihoods. Thus, retrofitting existing dams can help to mitigate these social and environmental issues.

Additionally, retrofitting dams can create and support hundreds of thousands of good-paying jobs that cannot be outsourced. A 2009 Navigant study indicates that installing 60,000 MW of hydropower would result in 1.4 million cumulative jobs by 2025, with 10,000 MW coming from converting non-powered dams.

Furthermore, investment costs per unit of installed capacity have fallen over time due to technological innovation, making the deployment of hydroelectric generation capabilities more economically viable. With ambitious targets from governments to decarbonize the grid by 2035 to avoid the worst effects of climate change, retrofitting dams presents a sustainable opportunity to increase hydropower generation capacity.

shunzap

The cost of hydropower installation is rising

The rising cost of hydropower installation can be attributed to several factors. Firstly, the construction of large hydroelectric dams requires significant investments in infrastructure. These projects often cost billions of dollars and are typically part of long-term economic development strategies spanning several decades. The large cost can be a barrier for many countries, especially those with limited financial resources.

Additionally, environmental and social concerns associated with dam construction have led to increased costs for mitigating negative impacts. Dams and reservoirs can reduce river flows, raise water temperatures, degrade water quality, and cause sediment buildup, which negatively affects wildlife and human communities. To address these issues, additional measures and technologies may be required, contributing to higher installation costs.

Moreover, the unpredictability of climate conditions poses challenges for hydropower generation. Droughts and extreme weather events can impact the availability of water, affecting the efficiency and productivity of hydroelectric systems. This uncertainty influences the planning and design of hydropower installations, potentially driving up costs to accommodate more resilient infrastructure and improved forecasting capabilities.

Despite the rising installation costs, hydropower remains a critical component of the global energy landscape. It offers lower levelized electricity costs compared to other energy sources due to reduced expenses in fuel, operation, and maintenance. The increasing demand for electricity continues to drive investments in hydroelectricity projects worldwide, with the global market value of hydropower projected to surpass 340 billion US dollars by 2030.

shunzap

Pumped storage hydro can balance electricity loads

Pumped-storage hydroelectricity (PSH) is a type of hydroelectric energy storage used by electric power systems for load balancing. PSH systems store energy in the form of gravitational potential energy of water, which is pumped from a lower elevation reservoir to a higher elevation one. During periods of high electrical demand, the stored water is released through turbines to produce electric power. PSH systems can also be used to balance baseload power plants and abate the fluctuating output of intermittent energy sources.

PSH systems are economical because they flatten out load variations on the power grid, allowing thermal power stations to operate at peak efficiency and reducing the need for "peaking" power plants. PSH acts as a giant battery, storing power and releasing it when needed. This flexibility is crucial in bringing more renewable resources onto the grid and securing stable power supplies. PSH systems can quickly increase or decrease the amount of power they generate, making them ideal for electricity grid reliability and stability.

PSH systems have large capacities and can run for long durations, providing reliable power when demand is high. They can also help stabilize electrical network frequency and provide reserve generation. Pumped storage plants can respond to load changes within seconds, much faster than thermal plants. PSH systems are particularly useful for managing the output of intermittent energy sources such as solar and wind power, which can be unpredictable.

While PSH systems have high capital costs, they have a long service life, in some cases exceeding a century. PSH is the world's largest battery technology, with a global installed capacity of nearly 200 GW, accounting for over 94% of long-duration energy storage capacity. PSH facilities can be found worldwide, with particularly high capacities in the United States and China.

Frequently asked questions

Hydroelectric dams require a consistent supply of water and a large amount of land. Some countries do not have these resources, and even those that do must weigh the benefits of hydropower against the environmental and social costs of dam construction.

Dams and reservoirs can reduce river flows, raise water temperatures, degrade water quality, and cause sediment buildup. Dams can also drastically change the landscape and rivers they are built on, impacting local communities and wildlife. For example, the construction of dams in the Columbia River Basin contributed to the decline in salmon and steelhead trout populations, which Tribal nations depended on for food.

Yes, one alternative is to retrofit existing dams to generate hydropower. This has been the primary source of hydropower development in the US since the 20th century. Another option is to upgrade existing hydropower facilities, retrofitting canals and conduits, and implementing limited development of new dams. Additionally, a technique called "pump back" can be used to store more energy in existing hydropower plants.

Hydropower is a good source of low-carbon electricity, and building more hydroelectric dams could help countries achieve their renewable energy goals. However, it is important to consider the potential environmental and social impacts and explore alternative sources of renewable energy, such as solar and wind power.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment