Front-Wheel Drive Electric Bikes: Damaging Or Not?

Electric bikes with front wheel drive have been criticised for their safety. Some users have reported accidents and injuries, including broken shoulders and mangled thumbs, which they blame on the front wheel drive. They argue that the powerful motor can cause the bike to become unstable, especially in wet conditions. However, others argue that the safety of front wheel drive electric bikes depends on a variety of factors, including the quality of the brakes and the rider's experience. Some older bikes may also have forks that are too weak to cope with the extra weight and stresses caused by the motor, which can lead to damage and safety issues over time.

Front wheel drive e-bikes can be dangerous in the wet

Front-wheel-drive e-bikes can be dangerous in the wet. One user of an e-bike forum reported that their front-wheel-drive e-bike threw them twice in the wet, with the second incident being more serious. They broke their shoulder and mangled their thumb. The user blamed the front-wheel drive of their e-bike for the accident. Another user agreed that wet pavement is "crazy slick" and that they can't afford another accident, so they only commute to work by bicycle on dry days. However, another user commented that they own two front-drive e-bikes and a rear-drive e-bike and they don't consider any of them less safe than the others. They pointed out that there are many factors to consider when it comes to the safety of e-bikes, such as the pedal assist and the brakes.

Older bikes may have forks too weak to cope with the extra weight and stresses caused by the motor

Older bikes may have forks that are too weak to cope with the extra weight and stresses caused by the motor. Over time, these stresses can damage and wear the fork, causing it to become unsafe. This means that you may need to upgrade your fork at an extra cost.

The extra weight and stresses caused by the motor can also affect the handling of the bike. This is especially true if the bike has a powerful motor with a throttle and pedelec. In these cases, the motor can provide a lot of power very quickly, which can be fun in dry conditions but can be dangerous in wet or icy conditions.

One user reported that they had broken their shoulder and mangled their thumb due to the front-wheel drive of their e-bike. They blamed the powerful motor, which was supposed to be only 200 watts but could reach speeds of 35 km/h by throttle alone.

Another user reported that they had lost control of their much heavier motorcycle in some loose material while trying to make a turn. They noted that there is always loose stuff or rocks that can throw the bike, and that they avoid riding in wet or icy conditions.

Despite these reports, one user who owns two front-drive e-bikes and a rear-drive bike does not consider any of them to be less safe than the others. They noted that there are many factors that contribute to the safety of an e-bike, such as the pedal assist and brakes.

Front wheel drive e-bikes can be safer than motorcycles

One user reports that they have owned two front-wheel-drive e-bikes and a rear-drive e-bike and does not consider any of them less safe than the others. They attribute this to the fact that e-bikes are ridden in a similar way to bicycles, and that users are already familiar with how to ride a bike.

However, it is important to note that older bikes may have forks that are too weak to cope with the extra weight and stresses caused by the motor. Over time, these stresses can damage and wear the fork, causing it to be unsafe. Therefore, it may be necessary to upgrade the fork at an additional cost.

Another user reports that they broke their shoulder and mangled their thumb in an accident that they blame on the front wheel drive of their e-bike. They claim that the motor is very powerful and can reach speeds of 35 km/hr by throttle alone. When pedalling, there is a delay of 1.5 seconds before the motor kicks in, which can be dangerous in wet conditions.

Despite these reports, it is important to consider the overall safety record of front wheel drive e-bikes compared to motorcycles. E-bikes are generally considered to be safer than motorcycles due to their lower speeds and the fact that they do not require a license to operate.

Front wheel drive e-bikes can be safer than rear wheel drive e-bikes

Another thing to consider is the pedal assist. The pedal assist will supply power whether or not you want it to apply power in certain situations. This can be a safety concern, especially if you are not used to riding an e-bike.

Additionally, the brakes on an e-bike may cut off power and lock the wheels. This can be dangerous if you are not expecting it, especially in slides where you rarely want to lock the brakes.

Some people have also reported accidents on front wheel drive e-bikes, blaming the powerful motor for their injuries. However, it is important to note that these accidents can also happen on rear wheel drive e-bikes, and it is up to the rider to be cautious and aware of their surroundings.

Front wheel drive e-bikes can be as safe as regular bikes

Some users have reported accidents and injuries while riding front wheel drive e-bikes, particularly in wet or icy conditions. However, it is important to note that these risks are not unique to front wheel drive e-bikes and can also occur with regular bikes.

The pedal assist on e-bikes can supply power whether the rider wants it to or not, which can be a safety concern in certain situations. Additionally, the brakes on e-bikes may cut off power and lock the wheels, which is not desirable in slides.

Overall, front wheel drive e-bikes can be as safe as regular bikes, but it is important to be aware of the potential risks and take appropriate precautions. This may include avoiding riding in wet or icy conditions, ensuring the bike is properly maintained, and being cautious when using the pedal assist and brakes.

Frequently asked questions